By

Tito Bucheli

Updated

May 3, 2024

Edited By

Fausto Bucheli Jr
Image Credit: Pexels

In Florida, the sunshine state known for its scenic drives, choosing between leasing and buying a car involves various factors. While the car itself is a crucial decision, car insurance shouldn’t be overlooked. Cheap Insurance explains the world of leasing vs. buying a car in Florida, helping you make an informed decision.

Key Takeaways:

  • Leasing vs. buying a car in Florida generally doesn’t directly affect auto insurance when getting the same insurance coverage.
  • Leased vehicles often require full coverage car insurance, increasing the cost.
  • Gap insurance is crucial for leased cars to cover the gap between the car’s value and the remaining lease balance in case of a total loss.
  • Leasing might involve additional costs like wear and tear insurance and limitations on modifications, requiring extra insurance.
  • Consider factors like car value, driving habits, mileage needs, and long-term ownership goals to choose the most affordable car insurance option, leasing or buying.

Does Leasing or Buying a Car Affect Car Insurance Rates in Florida?

Contrary to popular belief, leasing vs. buying a car generally doesn’t directly affect the price of car insurance in Florida. Insurance carriers primarily focus on the factors below.

  • Vehicle type: Sports cars and luxury vehicles typically have higher premiums due to their perceived higher risk.
  • Driving history: Accidents, tickets, and violations can significantly increase the cost of auto insurance in Florida.
  • Driver’s age and location: Younger and less experienced drivers often face higher rates. Location also plays a role, with urban areas generally having higher insurance costs than rural areas.
  • Annual mileage: Drivers with lower annual mileage may qualify for discounts.

What Car Insurance Coverage is Required for Leased Cars in Florida?

Florida law mandates car insurance for all drivers, regardless of leasing or ownership.

Property Damage Liability (PDL). Covers damage to another person’s property caused by your car in an accident.
Personal Injury Protection (PIP). Provides medical coverage for you and your passengers in case of an accident, regardless of fault. 

Leasing companies, however, often require additional auto insurance beyond the state minimum.

Comprehensive Coverage. Protects a leased car against theft, vandalism, and damage caused by natural disasters.
Collision CoveragePays for repairs to a leased car if it’s involved in a collision with another vehicle or object.
Gap Insurance (Optional). Covers the difference between the car’s actual cash value and the amount owed on the lease if it’s totaled.

Image Credit: Pexels

What Does The Role Gap Insurance Play In Leasing vs Buying?

Gap insurance is an optional coverage that bridges the gap between the car’s actual cash value and the amount owed on the lease or loan if the car is totaled.

Leasing: Gap insurance is highly recommended for leased vehicles. Since the car isn’t owned, the driver is still responsible for the remaining lease balance even after a total loss. Without gap insurance, the driver would be responsible for the difference between the car’s ACV and the remaining lease amount.
Buying: Gap insurance becomes less crucial as the owner builds equity in the car. However, it might still be beneficial for newer cars with a significant difference between the purchase price and the depreciating value.

Can Leasing Offer Any Advantages for Affordable Car Insurance in Florida?

Leasing might offer some advantages for vehicle insurance in specific situations.

  • Lower value vehicles: Leased cars are typically newer models with a higher depreciating value. Since auto insurance quotes are partly based on the car’s value, leased vehicles might have slightly lower car insurance costs compared to owning a car with a similar value.
  • Low mileage drivers: Drive fewer miles annually, the car owner might qualify for lower mileage discounts offered by some auto insurance carriers. This could be beneficial for leasing, as mileage restrictions are often part of the lease agreement.

Are There Additional Car Insurance Costs to Consider When Leasing in Florida?

Leasing can incur additional auto insurance costs beyond the required coverages. 

  • Wear and Tear Insurance: Leasing agreements typically outline acceptable wear and tear on the vehicle at the lease-end inspection. However, exceeding those standards can result in hefty fees. Wear and tear is an optional insurance add-on to the policy that helps mitigate these charges. It typically covers minor scratches, dents, and excessive tire wear, offering financial protection against unexpected costs at lease termination. The cost of this coverage varies depending on the car’s value, lease term, and the insurance carrier. Carefully weigh the repair costs against the cost for wear and tear insurance to determine if it’s a worthwhile investment.

     

  • Non-Standard Modifications: Leasing companies often have strict guidelines regarding modifications made to their vehicles. These might include restrictions on aftermarket parts, window tinting, or even certain types of car washes. If the driver plans on customizing your leased car beyond factory specifications, it’s crucial to discuss these modifications with a leasing company and insurance provider beforehand. In some cases, some might need to obtain additional insurance to ensure your modifications are covered in case of an accident or theft. Unauthorized modifications could violate the lease agreement and potentially lead to additional fees or even lease termination.


Leasing vs. buying a car doesn’t significantly affect the price of 
automobile insurance in Florida. However, leasing often requires full coverage car insurance, which can increase your premium. Gap insurance is another cost consideration, especially crucial for leased vehicles.

Ultimately, the most affordable car insurance option depends on factors like the car’s value, your driving habits, and the chosen coverages. Carefully compare auto insurance quotes from different insurance companies before committing.