Tito Bucheli


March 26, 2024

Edited By

Fausto Bucheli Jr
Key in front door.
Image Credits: PhotoMIX-Company

Setting the Stage

Does Renter’s Insurance Really Matter?

Skimping on coverage could leave you financially exposed in the event of unforeseen mishaps. Imagine this:

  • A kitchen fire damages your apartment, rendering it unlivable. Without renters insurance, you’d be responsible for temporary housing, repairs, and replacing all your belongings, which can be a hefty financial burden.
  • Stolen electronics and jewelry. Replacing these items out of pocket could significantly strain your budget.
  • A guest trips and injures themselves in your apartment. If they sue, you could be liable for medical bills and legal fees if you do not have liability rental insurance coverage.

These are just a few examples of how unexpected events can turn into major financial setbacks without proper 
renters insurance. Follow along, as Cheap Insurance shares insight on the advantages of affordable renters insurance coverage.

Key Takeaways:

  • Low cost renters insurance: With lower renters insurance rates, you get limited coverage, higher deductibles and can leave you financially exposed.
  • Understand coverage limitations: Not all policies cover standard perils like water damage or offer personal liability protection. Carefully review exclusions and limits before choosing best renters insurance option.
  • Itemized lists vs. ACV: Choosing an itemized list for reimbursement can be crucial to maximize compensation for valuable belongings, which requires effort and documentation.
  • Balance affordability with protection: Don’t sacrifice comprehensive Insurance coverage for the sake of a lower insurance rate. Consider your risk tolerance, claims history, and desired level of protection before making a decision.

Common Mishaps and Coverage

Fire, Flood, Theft! What Does Renters Insurance Typically Cover?

Most renters insurance policies typically cover standard perils:

Fire and smoke damage: This covers damage caused by fire, lightning, and smoke.

Theft: Reimburses you for stolen personal belongings, up to your policy limit.

Vandalism: Covers damage to your belongings caused by intentional acts of destruction.

Get Insurance On These Often Overlooked Situations?

Consider these often overlooked situations:

Water damage: Caused by burst pipes or sewer backups.

Personal liability: This covers medical bills and legal fees if someone gets injured in your apartment and sues you.

Additional living expenses: If your apartment or home becomes unlivable due to a covered peril, your insurance might help with temporary housing costs.

Make sure your insurance policy covers these situations, especially if you live in an area prone to certain risks.

Itemized vs. Actual Cash Value

When facing a loss and filing a claim with your renters insurance, understanding the two main payout options is crucial: itemized lists and actual cash value (ACV).

Itemized List: A Detailed Approach with Potential Rewards

This option involves creating a comprehensive list of your belongings, including descriptions, purchase dates, receipts (if available), and estimated current replacement costs. While time-consuming to maintain, an accurate and up-to-date itemized list offers several advantages:

Higher Reimbursement: You get reimbursed for the current replacement cost of your belongings, potentially maximizing your compensation. Remember, replacement costs often exceed the depreciated value, especially for electronics and appliances.

Greater Control: You have more control over how the claim is settled, potentially negotiating values with the insurance company based on your documentation.

Peace of Mind: Having detailed records reduces the burden of proving ownership and value during the claims process.

However, there are also drawbacks to consider

Effort Required: Maintaining comprehensive renters insurance and updated list requires consistent effort, including documenting new purchases and updating values.

Potential Scrutiny: Be prepared for the insurance company to scrutinize your list and potentially request additional documentation to verify values.


Actual Cash Value (ACV): The Simpler, Yet Potentially Costlier, Route

This option allows for a quicker claims process, as the insurance company determines the depreciated value of your belongings at the time of loss. While seemingly convenient, several limitations could leave you financially exposed:

Lower Reimbursement: You receive the depreciated value of your belongings, often significantly less than their current replacement cost. This can be a major disadvantage, especially for newer items.

Limited Negotiation Power: Your ability to negotiate values is usually restricted, as the ACV is determined based on pre-established depreciation schedules.

Burden of Proof: You might still need to provide proof of ownership and value, even though the insurer uses their own depreciation tables.

While some policies might default to ACV, others might offer the choice between itemized lists and ACV. Here’s what to consider before making your decision:

Value of Your Belongings: If you own valuable items like electronics, jewelry, or artwork, an itemized list can significantly increase your reimbursement potential.

Recordkeeping Habits: If you’re comfortable maintaining detailed records and updating them regularly, an itemized list might be a good fit.

Policy Limitations: Carefully review your policy details to understand if it offers the itemized list option and any associated restrictions.

Opting for the best renters insurance policy and carefully selecting the appropriate coverage option can provide better insurance protection and peace of mind when facing unforeseen events.

Apartment Buildings.
Image Credit: mustafaunlu09

Navigating Claims and Costs

Can My Renters Insurance Rate Increase After a Claim?

Filing a claim isn’t guaranteed to raise your renters insurance rate.¬† Remember, insurance companies assess risk and adjust the rate based on individual claims history. While the impact might vary, here’s what you need to know:

Claim Related Renters Insurance Rate Increases

Filing a claim, regardless of fault, can potentially lead to rate increases at renewal. This is because you’ve demonstrated a higher risk profile by utilizing your insurance. The extent of the increase depends on various factors, including:

Severity of the claim: Larger claims generally lead to higher premium increases compared to smaller ones.

Frequency of claims: Multiple claims within a short period significantly increase the likelihood of a premium hike.

Insurance company’s policy: Each company has its own guidelines for adjusting premiums based on claims history.

Before facing a claim, familiarize yourself with your policy’s specific terms regarding claim related rate increases.

  • Claims forgiveness: Some policies offer forgiveness for a specific number of claims within a certain timeframe, keeping your premium stable.
  • Increase caps: Check for limitations on how much your insurance rate can increase after a claim.
  • Company history: Research the insurer’s reputation and track record regarding covering claims.


Remember that claim-related premium increases aren’t solely determined by the cost of the claim itself. Other factors can influence the impact:

  • Type of claim: Water damage or theft, might be viewed as more risky by insurers, potentially leading to higher premium increases compared to fire damage.
  • Deductible: Choosing a¬†higher deductible¬†can sometimes lower your initial premium, but remember, you’ll pay more out of pocket before your insurance starts paying. This might be strategically beneficial if you’re confident in avoiding small claims that could trigger premium hikes.
  • Claims history across policies: If you have a history of claims on other insurance policies like¬†auto insurance¬†or¬†motorcycle insurance, it might affect your renters insurance rate, even if the claims weren’t related to your renters insurance policy.
Image Credit: ElasticComputeFarm

Finding the Right Balance:

Finding Affordable Renters Insurance That Doesn’t Compromise Protection.

Finding affordable renters insurance without sacrificing coverage is possible. Here are some tips:

  • Shop around and compare inexpensive renters insurance quotes: Don’t settle for the first offer. Get¬†renters insurance quotes¬†from different insurance companies and compare coverage details, deductibles, and limits.
  • Increase your deductible: Raising your deductible can get you a lower renters insurance rate, but remember you will pay more out of pocket for claims. Balance affordability with your risk tolerance.
  • Bundle your policies: Many insurers offer¬†discounts for bundling¬†renters insurance with car insurance and motorcycle insurance.
  • Renters insurance discounts: Ask about discounts for good credit, student discounts, member affiliations and young professionals.
  • Protection Devices: Some insurance companies offer discounted renters insurance policies when smart home devices, alarm systems and video cameras.


Find the cheapest renters insurance with the coverage that fits your budget and provides the right insurance protection. Compare renters insurance quotes, prioritize the insurance coverage you need and choose a renters policy that offers peace of mind without breaking the bank.