By

John Davey

Updated

September 1, 2023

Edited By

Fausto Bucheli Jr
couple shocked by their car insurance bill
image credit - Mikhail Nilov

Auto insurance rates continue to rise in 2023. There are a number of factors contributing to this trend, including the increasing cost of repairs, the rising number of uninsured drivers, and the use of more expensive cars. In this article, CheapInsurance.com will discuss the reasons why auto insurance rates are increasing, and what you can do to lower your rates.

Troubling Trend: Auto Insurance Rates Continue To Increase

Auto insurance rates have been steadily increasing in recent years, and there are a number of factors that are contributing to this trend. These include:

The increasing cost of claims.
The cost of car insurance claims has been rising steadily in recent years, due to factors such as the increasing cost of repairs and medical care.

The increasing number of uninsured drivers.
The number of uninsured drivers in the United States has been increasing in recent years, which has also contributed to the rising cost of car insurance.

State regulations.
Some states have enacted regulations that have made it more difficult for insurance companies to make a profit, which has led to higher rates.

The COVID-19 pandemic.
The COVID-19 pandemic has also had an impact on auto insurance rates, as the decrease in driving during the pandemic led to a decrease in premiums. However, as driving has increased since the pandemic, rates have started to rise again.

Specific Insurance companies non-renewing policies, or not accepting new policies in some states like Florida and Georgia, California and others

In recent years, some insurance companies have stopped renewing policies or accepting new policies in certain states. This is often due to the high cost of claims in those states. For example, Florida has some of the highest auto insurance rates in the country, and several insurance companies have stopped offering coverage in the state.

Insurance Companies Leaving California, Georgia, and Florida

In recent months, several major insurance companies have announced that they are leaving or reducing their car insurance availability in California, Georgia, and Florida. These states are all considered to be high-risk markets due to a combination of factors, including high rates of uninsured drivers, frequent natural disasters, and rising litigation costs.

In California, State Farm, Allstate, and Geico have all announced that they are halting new policy sales in the state. These companies cited a number of reasons for their decision, including rising costs, increasing competition, and changes in the state’s insurance laws.

In Georgia, Progressive and Nationwide have both announced that they are reducing the number of policies they will offer in the state. These companies said that the decision was made due to the high cost of claims in Georgia.

In Florida, Farmers Insurance has announced that it is leaving the state altogether. The company said that it was no longer able to offer affordable insurance in Florida due to the state’s high risk of hurricanes and other natural disasters.

The departure of these major insurance companies is a major concern for drivers in these states. It could lead to higher rates, fewer choices, and less competition in the car insurance market.

What are the reasons for insurance companies leaving these states?

There are a number of reasons why insurance companies are leaving or reducing their car insurance availability in California, Georgia, and Florida. These include:

  • High rates of uninsured drivers: Uninsured drivers are a major problem in all three states. In California, for example, an estimated 1 in 10 drivers are uninsured. This means that if you are involved in an accident with an uninsured driver, you may not be able to recover your losses.
  • Frequent natural disasters: California, Georgia, and Florida are all prone to natural disasters, such as hurricanes, wildfires, and floods. These disasters can cause billions of dollars in damage, and insurance companies often lose money on claims related to these events.
  • Rising litigation costs: The cost of litigation has been rising in recent years, and this is putting a strain on insurance companies. In California, for example, the average cost of a car accident lawsuit is now over $1 million.
  • Changes in state insurance laws: State insurance laws have been changing in recent years, and this has made it more difficult for insurance companies to operate in some states. For example, California has recently passed a law that requires insurance companies to offer more coverage options to consumers. This has made it more difficult for insurance companies to make a profit in the state.

What can drivers do?

The departure of major insurance companies from California, Georgia, and Florida is a major concern for drivers in these states. However, there are a few things that drivers can do to protect themselves:

  • Shop around for car insurance: Compare rates from multiple insurance companies before you buy a policy. This is especially important in states where there are fewer insurance companies competing for business.
  • Consider alternative insurance options: There are a number of alternative insurance options available, such as rideshare insurance and non-standard insurance. These options may be a good choice for drivers who have difficulty finding traditional car insurance.
  • Be a safe driver: The best way to reduce your insurance costs is to be a safe driver. This means driving defensively, obeying the law, and avoiding accidents.

The departure of major insurance companies from California, Georgia, and Florida is a sign of the challenges facing the car insurance industry. Drivers in these states should be prepared to shop around for car insurance and consider alternative insurance options.

Many States Delayed Granting Insurance Company Rate Increase Requests for two years

In some states, insurance companies have been unable to get rate increase approvals for several years. This is due to state regulations that make it difficult for insurance companies to raise rates. For example, in California, many insurance companies have been unable to get rate increase approvals since 2019. The California Department of Insurance only recently in 2023 began granting some rate increases after three years of no rate increase. Insurance companies responded by immediately filing for another round of rate increase requests

Which insurance companies did get rate increases in 2023?

In 2023, several insurance companies have gotten rate increases in some states. For example, Geico got a 12% rate increase in Florida, and Progressive got a 10% rate increase in California.

The increasing cost of new cars, and the increasing cost of car repair

The increasing cost of new cars is also contributing to the rising cost of car insurance. This is because the cost of repairs is also increasing. For example, the average cost of repairing a car following major damage has increased by more than 50% in recent years.

Recent Increase in Car Insurance Premiums

The average cost of car insurance has been increasing in recent years. According to a recent study by the Insurance Information Institute, the average annual premium for car insurance in the United States is now $1,674. This is up from $1,548 in 2022.

There are a number of factors that have contributed to the recent increase in car insurance premiums. These include:

  • The rising cost of repairs. The cost of car parts and labor has been increasing in recent years, which has led to higher insurance claims.
  • The increasing number of uninsured drivers. The number of uninsured drivers in the United States has been increasing in recent years. This means that insurance companies have to pay more for claims, which is passed on to policyholders in the form of higher premiums.
  • The use of more expensive cars. The average price of a new car has been increasing in recent years. This means that insurance companies have to pay more to repair or replace cars in the event of an accident.


The increase in car insurance premiums has been felt most by high-risk drivers.
High-risk drivers are those who have a history of accidents or traffic violations. The average annual premium for high-risk drivers is now $2,725.

Standard risk drivers are those who have a clean driving record. The average annual premium for standard risk drivers is now $1,574.

Preferred risk drivers are those who have a good driving record and other factors that make them less likely to be involved in an accident. The average annual premium for preferred risk drivers is now $1,323.

The Possibility of Car Insurance Rates Decreasing in the Next Five Years

Car insurance rates have been on the rise in recent years, due to a number of factors, including the increasing cost of repairs, the rising number of uninsured drivers, and the growing use of technology in cars. However, there are some reasons to believe that car insurance rates could start to decrease in the next five years.

Decreasing Cost of Repairs

One reason is that the cost of repairs is starting to plateau. The cost of car parts has been increasing in recent years, but this trend is beginning to slow down. Additionally, the use of newer technologies in cars is making them safer and less likely to be involved in accidents. This could lead to lower insurance claims, which could in turn lead to lower insurance rates.

For example, a study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found that the average cost of repairing a car involved in a collision decreased by 1.8% from 2018 to 2019. This was the first time in five years that the cost of repairs had decreased.

Increased Use of Telematics

Another reason to be optimistic about car insurance rates is the increasing use of telematics. Telematics is the use of technology to track driving behavior. Insurance companies are starting to offer discounts to drivers who agree to have their driving tracked. This could lead to lower rates for safe drivers.

For example, a study by State Farm found that drivers who use its Drivewise telematics program have an average of 13% fewer accidents than non-users. This means that State Farm can afford to offer discounts to Drivewise users, without having to raise rates for other drivers.

Growing Popularity of Ride-Sharing Services

Finally, the growing popularity of ride-sharing services could also lead to lower car insurance rates. Ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft are becoming more and more popular, which means that fewer people are owning cars. This could lead to a decrease in the number of accidents, which could in turn lead to lower insurance rates.

For example, a study by the University of California, Berkeley found that the introduction of Uber in San Francisco led to a 10% decrease in the number of traffic fatalities. This is because Uber drivers are more likely to be experienced and to have a clean driving record.

Examples of Car Insurance Rates Decreasing in the Past 20 Years

There have been a few examples of car insurance rates decreasing in the past 20 years. For example, in 2008, the average cost of car insurance in the United States decreased by 1.5%. This was due to a number of factors, including the economic recession and the decrease in the number of accidents.

In 2013, the average cost of car insurance in the United States decreased by 0.7%. This was due to the increasing use of telematics and the decreasing cost of repairs.

It is possible that car insurance rates will continue to decrease in the next five years. However, it is also possible that they will continue to increase. The factors that will affect car insurance rates in the future are complex and uncertain.

 

Couple getting car insurance quotes
image credit – Mikhail Nilov

Tips for Saving Money on Car Insurance

If you are looking to save money on car insurance, here are a few tips:

  • Shop around and compare quotes from different companies.
  • Get quotes from multiple companies.
  • Get discounts for things like good driving behavior, anti-theft devices, and a clean driving record.
  • Bundle your car insurance with other types of insurance, such as homeowners or renters insurance.
  • Increase your deductible. This will lower your monthly premiums, but you will have to pay more out of pocket in the event of an accident.
  • Drive safely and avoid accidents. This will help you maintain a good driving record, which can qualify you for discounts.

Why Do Insurance Companies Reduce or Stop Offering Coverage in Certain States?

Insurance companies are businesses, and like all businesses, they need to make a profit. If they can’t make a profit in a particular state, they may reduce or stop offering coverage in that state.

There are a number of reasons why insurance companies might not be able to make a profit in a particular state. These include:

  • The cost of claims is too high. This could be due to a number of factors, such as the number of accidents, the severity of the accidents, or the cost of repairs.
  • The number of uninsured drivers is too high. This means that insurance companies have to pay more for claims, which can make it difficult to make a profit.
  • The state’s regulations are too restrictive. This could make it difficult for insurance companies to operate in the state or to offer the types of coverage that they want to offer.
  • The state’s economy is weak. This could lead to fewer people being able to afford car insurance, which can also make it difficult for insurance companies to make a profit.

In some cases, insurance companies may reduce or stop offering coverage in a particular state even if they are making a profit. This could be because they are concerned about the future of the state’s economy or because they believe that the state’s regulations are too restrictive.

If an insurance company reduces or stops offering coverage in a particular state, it can be difficult for drivers in that state to find affordable car insurance. This is because there are fewer insurance companies competing for business, which can lead to higher premiums.

When Will the Trend of Insurance Companies Limiting Car Insurance Coverage, or Completely Leaving Certain States Begin to Change?

The trend of insurance companies limiting car insurance coverage or completely leaving certain states is a complex one, and there is no easy answer to the question of when it will change. However, there are a few factors that could influence the trend in the future.

One factor is the cost of claims. If the cost of claims continues to increase, it could make it more difficult for insurance companies to make a profit in certain states. This could lead to further reductions in coverage or even complete withdrawals from some markets.

Another factor is the number of uninsured drivers. If the number of uninsured drivers continues to increase, it could also make it more difficult for insurance companies to make a profit. This is because insurance companies have to pay for the claims of uninsured drivers, even if they are not at fault in an accident.

The state’s regulations could also play a role in the trend. If state regulations become too restrictive, it could make it more difficult for insurance companies to operate in a particular state. This could lead to reductions in coverage or even complete withdrawals from some markets.

Finally, the state’s economy could also influence the trend. If the state’s economy weakens, it could lead to fewer people being able to afford car insurance. This could also make it more difficult for insurance companies to make a profit in a particular state.

It is difficult to say for sure when the trend of insurance companies limiting car insurance coverage or completely leaving certain states will begin to change. However, the factors discussed above could all play a role in the future of the trend.

Here are some possible ways to change the trend:

  • States could pass laws that make it easier for insurance companies to operate in the state. This could include laws that reduce the cost of claims or that make it easier for insurance companies to collect premiums from uninsured drivers.
  • States could offer subsidies to help drivers afford car insurance. This could make it easier for drivers to get coverage, even in states where insurance companies are struggling to make a profit.
  • Technology could be used to reduce the cost of claims. For example, the use of telematics could help insurance companies identify safe drivers and offer them discounts.


By taking these and other steps, states could help to reverse the trend of insurance companies limiting car insurance coverage or completely leaving certain states.

What to do if your car insurance company stops offering insurance coverage in your state?

It can be a hassle when your car insurance company stops offering insurance coverage in your state. Here are the steps you need to take:

Contact your insurance company. Once you find out that your insurance company is no longer offering coverage in your state, you should contact them immediately. They will be able to tell you why they are discontinuing coverage and what your options are.

Get quotes from other companies. Once you know why your insurance company is discontinuing coverage, you can start shopping around for quotes from other companies. Be sure to compare rates and coverage options carefully.

Read the fine print. Before you switch to a new company, be sure to read the fine print of your new policy carefully. Make sure you understand the coverage limits and exclusions.

Ask about discounts. Many insurance companies offer discounts for things like good driving behavior, anti-theft devices, and a clean driving record. Be sure to ask about any discounts that you may qualify for.

Be prepared to switch companies if you find a better deal. The insurance industry is competitive, so it’s important to be prepared to switch companies if you find a better deal.

Here are some additional tips for finding a new car insurance company:

Get quotes from several different companies. This will give you a good idea of the rates and coverage options available to you.

Compare rates and coverage options carefully. Make sure you understand the fine print of each policy before you make a decision.

Read reviews of different companies online. This can help you get a sense of what other customers have experienced.

Ask friends and family for recommendations. They may have had a good experience with a particular company.

By following these tips, you can find a new car insurance company that meets your needs and budget.

Here are some additional things to keep in mind:

You may be able to get a grace period from your current insurance company to allow you time to find a new one.

If you have an accident while your policy is still in effect, your current insurance company may still cover you. However, you may have to pay a higher premium in the future.

If you are unable to find a new insurance company, you may be able to get coverage through the state’s assigned risk pool. This is a last resort option, as the rates are typically higher than with a private company.